Homemade Peppermint Liqueur

Naturally made without artificial colors or flavors, this homemade peppermint liqueur is a wonderful alternative to store-bought peppermint schnapps. It’s the perfect addition to holiday-inspired cocktails and also makes a great gift. (I’ve even included a free printable label for you to use!)

Despite the fact that we have a pretty well-stocked bar in our kitchen for entertaining guests, we actually rarely drink alcohol. Don’t get me wrong, we do enjoy a glass or two of red wine when dining on the weekends. Other than that, most alcohol doesn’t appeal that much to us anymore.

The holidays, though, are a bit of an exception.

Making Homemade Liqueurs

It all began a few years back when I found a pretty holiday book about how to make your own liqueurs. 

I was amazed by how easily I could transform a generic vodka into whatever type of liqueur that appealed to me. The book showed how to make basic liqueurs like homemade coffee liqueur and orange liqueur, mimicking Kahlúa and Cointreau. 

Why Make Your Own Liqueurs?

What’s great about making your own is that you can make just about anything you can imagine.

Making your own liqueurs can also save you money. Save the more expensive vodka for mixed drinks or cocktails where you’ll better appreciate the difference. For homemade liqueurs, the flavor will be changed and diluted so that it’s not as important to choose brand names. That said, even when choosing more expensive vodka, once you’ve added the sweetener, in most cases you’ll still save money over brand name liqueurs.

Add to all of that the fact that you can choose the quality of the ingredients. I chose to use organic coffee beans when making my homemade Tía María/Kahlúa. I also used organic lemons from my own tree for my homemade limoncello. When making this peppermint liqueur, I used organic mint leaves from my own garden. You may prefer using something different. That’s the beauty of it. You get to choose.

Other homemade liqueurs

I began experimenting and first made my own coffee liqueur. Later, I tried making orange liqueur and a homemade limoncello. Using the same idea, I also made limecello and mandarincello and found the best way to make them. (I wrote about my experiments in the post on making limoncello.)

One of our favorites was praline liqueur. When I first wrote this post, I was brewing up a new batch and promised to show you how to make it yourself. Somehow life happened, and I never got to it. (Now that I’ve been reminded, I may make it a priority again.)

I also made a nice holiday liqueur by infusing dried cranberries in vodka and made cream liqueurs by adding sweetened condensed milk. See? The sky is the limit to what you can make!

Homemade liqueurs as gifts

I’ve always loved to make things myself. Even as a kid, I began making all of my Christmas gifts. 

One year I hand-painted ceramics. My grandmother proudly displayed the reindeer statues I gave her each Christmas. Another year, I painted some not-so-successful oil paintings that ended up in people’s basements. (I guess all of those weekend mornings watching Bob Ross didn’t really pay off as well as I thought.) 😉

As I got older, I also became more practical. I branched out into foodie gifts and one year I made liqueurs.

My praline liqueur became the most-wanted repeat gift each year for a special someone (my grandmother’s husband).

All in the presentation

Success in gift-giving encouraged me to keep on. Each year I would find a new pretty bottle for gifting that year’s liqueur. If I didn’t find a bottle that I especially loved, I put more effort into making beautiful hand-painted labels or in decorating the bottles with something special.

I think it’s fun to decorate the bottles you give away to further personalize the gift and make it special. For these bottles, I made labels and also wrapped the bottle with a homemade baker’s twine. Baker’s twine works perfectly for this liqueur because the red and white stripes are reminiscent of peppermint candy.

Printable Label

I also designed a label for my liqueur and printed it out onto a thin waterproof photo paper. I then cut it out and glued it into place.

Here is the label I used. It’s a transparent png file, so you can even print it onto transparent labels if you prefer. Feel free to print it out and use it! Just right click on the image and save it. Resize it to fit your particular bottle and then print at that size.

Making a natural peppermint liqueur

Making a homemade peppermint liqueur from fresh mint leaves is actually quite simple.

You will need:

• Fresh mint leaves (or peppermint extract and/or essential oil)
• Vodka (or other unflavored alcohol)
• Filtered water
• Sugar

Part 1: Make a Peppermint extract

The first step to making a homemade peppermint liqueur is to make the peppermint extract. This is done by infusing the mint leaves into a strong alcohol over the course of several days to weeks. Ideally, you’ll want to choose a non-flavored vodka of around 40% (80 proof), but can also try using other strong liquors like rum.

Once the first step is finished, you can use the peppermint extract as-is or can sweeten it to make the liqueur.

Using extracts or essential oils

Over the years, I’ve seen several ways suggested for making peppermint liqueur. Some people use strong peppermint extracts (and often also add green food coloring). Other people use essential oils to flavor the vodka. Either felt a bit like cheating to me.

I do have to admit, though, that either of those options will give you a nice, clear, colorless peppermint liqueur that is is very quick and simple to make! So, if you’re looking for a last-minute DIY liqueur, then I guess you may want to consider adding extracts or essential oils for the first part of flavoring the alcohol.

I haven’t personally made peppermint liqueur using either, so I’m not sure how much you really need to add. My best guess is that you’ll need to add quite a bit of extract. On the other hand, essential oils are a lot more concentrated so I doubt you’d need to add much to strongly flavor the alcohol.

If I were going to make a liqueur this way, I’d experiment by adding a little bit, taste-testing it, and adding more, in small increments, as needed.

Using Fresh mint leaves

If, on the other hand, you are more hardcore like me, you may prefer making peppermint liqueur completely from scratch. To do so, you’ll want to get your hands on a bunch of fresh mint leaves.

• 

• 

• 

• 

• Rinse your mint leaves and place them in a large glass jar. (To make around 1 liter of liqueur, I used around 3 cups of fresh mint leaves.)
• Cover them with vodka until completely, or almost completely, covered. (I used around 3.5 cups.)
• Let them steep for several weeks. For the first few days, stir the mixture or dunk any exposed leaves under the surface of the alcohol. This prevents mold from forming on the leaves. After several days the leaves will reduce in volume and will sink to the bottom of the jar more easily.
• Once the mint leaves stay under the surface on their own, you can occasionally shake them or stir them if you remember, but it isn’t a necessary step. I left the leaves steeping for just over a month, but you really don’t need to leave them that long!
• Strain out the leaves from your vodka. I usually use a stainless steel strainer placed into a funnel.
• The strained liquid is your homemade peppermint extract! Save a little bit of it in a separate bottle for recipes, if you like.

Part 2: Sweetening the liqueur

To convert the extract into liqueur, we need to sweeten it. Normally, a simple sugar syrup is used. It helps sweeten and dilute the alcohol while slightly increasing its viscosity.

Making a simple sugar syrup

• To make the syrup, dissolve 1 part sugar to 1 part water over medium heat, stirring until the sugar has completely dissolved. (I used 1 cup of demerara sugar and 1 cup of water.)
• Remove the sugar mixture from the heat and let it cool.

Part 3: Putting it all together

To finish making your liqueur, we need to add the sugar syrup to the homemade peppermint extract. This part can be done to taste.

I used around 3 parts vodka (just over 3 cups) to 1 part sugar syrup (the 1 cup homemade syrup), but you can make it more or less sweet to suit your taste buds.