Natural preservatives for DIY skincare and cosmetics
If you make homemade skincare or cosmetics, understanding preservatives is essential. This guide explains when you need them, how they work, and which natural preservative systems are the most reliable.
Over the years, I’ve gotten a lot of questions about how to preserve homemade skincare and cosmetic products and which preservatives are actually worth using.
As more people become interested in making their own products, there’s also been growing interest in using gentler, more natural ingredients and avoiding certain preservatives or additives. I’m one of those people too. I enjoy making my own skincare and cosmetics because it gives me more control over the ingredients I use and helps me customize products for my own needs and preferences.
That said, “natural” doesn’t automatically mean safe or self-preserving. Even products made with high-quality ingredients can become contaminated with bacteria, mold, or yeast if they aren’t formulated properly. Understanding when and how to preserve homemade products is an important part of making safe DIY cosmetics.
Why use a preservative?
When people first start making homemade skincare products, they often focus mostly on choosing natural oils, butters, and other active ingredients. Just as important, though, is making sure the final product stays safe to use over time.
Microbes such as bacteria, yeast, and mold can grow in skincare products, especially those that contain water or water-based ingredients. While mold is often easy to spot, bacterial contamination is usually invisible. A product can look, smell, and feel completely normal while still containing microbial growth.
Not all microbes are harmful, but some can cause irritation, spoilage, breakouts, or infections. Contaminated products have been linked to skin issues such as folliculitis, and products used around the eyes or on sensitive or damaged skin need extra care because contamination can pose a real infection risk.
Proper preservation helps slow the growth of unwanted microbes and is an important part of making safe, stable homemade lotions, creams, shampoos, conditioners, and other water-based products.
When do you need a preservative?
In general, any product that contains water or water-based ingredients needs a broad-spectrum preservative. Water creates an environment where bacteria, yeast, and mold can grow.
Products that usually need a preservative include:
- Lotions and creams
- Shampoos and conditioners
- Facial toners and sprays
- Products made with aloe vera, hydrosols, teas, or herbal infusions
- Emulsions that combine water and oils
Products that usually do NOT need a preservative include:
- Pure oils
- Salves or balms
- Balm bars or lotion bars
- Anhydrous body butters
- Wax-based products
- True soap bars
Products that may still need a preservative
Some products fall somewhere in between. Sugar scrubs, for example, may not contain water initially, but they’re often used in the shower where water can easily contaminate the container. In cases like that, adding a preservative is usually a good idea.
The same can apply to other anhydrous products that are regularly exposed to water or used with wet hands. Once water is introduced into the container, microbial growth becomes much more likely.
Water-based products
Water-based products are especially prone to microbial growth because bacteria, yeast, and mold thrive in moist environments. Even products that look and smell perfectly normal can become contaminated over time.
This is especially important for emulsions like lotions and creams because they combine water and oils into a stable mixture that can support microbial growth throughout the product.
Ingredients like aloe vera, hydrosols, herbal infusions, milk, and fresh botanical ingredients can make products even more difficult to preserve properly.
Why true soap is different
True soap is somewhat unique because its naturally high pH makes it much less hospitable to microbial growth than most other homemade skincare products.
Traditional bar soaps and liquid soaps made with lye typically have a pH of around 9–10 or higher. At that pH, most bacteria, yeast, and mold struggle to grow, which is why true soap is often considered self-preserving.
That’s one reason properly made soap bars and undiluted liquid soap paste can usually be stored for long periods without needing a broad-spectrum preservative.
Diluted liquid soap is a bit more debated in DIY circles, but the naturally high pH still makes it far less prone to microbial growth than lotions, creams, or surfactant-based cleansers.
It’s important to note, though, that this only applies to true soap made with lye. Syndet products, such as many homemade shampoos, body washes, and facial cleansers made with surfactants, usually have a lower pH and do require a preservative if they contain water.
Preservatives for liquid soap
One reason liquid soap creates so much confusion is that most preservatives used in skincare products aren’t effective at the high pH of true soap. Many common cosmetic preservatives only work well in products with a pH below 6, while properly made liquid soap usually has a pH closer to 9–10 or higher.
For that reason, many soapmakers rely on the naturally high pH of the soap itself rather than adding a preservative. Properly made liquid soap paste is generally considered very shelf stable and can usually be stored for long periods without issues.
That said, contamination risks can increase if you add ingredients like milk, botanical extracts, fresh aloe, or other difficult-to-preserve additives after dilution. In those cases, preservation becomes much more complicated.
One preservative often mentioned for high-pH products is Suttocide™ A (Sodium Hydroxymethylglycinate), which is marketed as effective in higher-pH formulations like liquid soap. Some formulators also experiment with preservatives like Glydant Plus, although many common cosmetic preservatives are not considered reliable at typical soap pH levels.
Even when working with high-pH soap, good manufacturing practices still matter. Clean equipment, distilled water, and proper storage all help reduce contamination risks.
Anhydrous products
Anhydrous products are products that do not contain water or water-based ingredients. This includes products made only with oils, butters, waxes, and oil-soluble additives.
Because microbes need water to grow, properly formulated anhydrous products are generally much less prone to microbial contamination and usually do not require a broad-spectrum preservative.
Examples include:
- Body butters
- Salves and balms
- Lotion bars
- Facial oils
- Wax-based products
That said, oils can still go rancid over time. Antioxidants like vitamin E or rosemary extract can help slow oxidation and extend shelf life, but they are not broad-spectrum preservatives and do not prevent microbial growth.
Anhydrous products and humidity
Even if a product does not contain water initially, it can still become contaminated during use.
Products used in the shower, such as sugar scrubs, are especially prone to contamination because water can easily enter the container through wet hands, steam, or condensation.
Once water is introduced into an otherwise anhydrous product, microbial growth becomes much more likely. For products that are regularly exposed to moisture, adding a preservative or using packaging that minimizes contamination can be a good idea.
Ingredients that are NOT preservatives
Just because an ingredient has antioxidant or antimicrobial properties doesn’t automatically mean it can safely preserve a homemade cosmetic product. Many ingredients commonly promoted as “natural preservatives” are not considered reliable broad-spectrum preservatives when used alone.
Vitamin E
Vitamin E is one of the most commonly misunderstood ingredients in DIY skincare.
While it’s often referred to as a preservative, vitamin E is actually an antioxidant, not a broad-spectrum preservative. It helps slow the oxidation of oils and can help extend the shelf life of oil-based products by delaying rancidity.
That makes it a great addition to body oils, balms, salves, and body butters, but it does not prevent the growth of bacteria, yeast, or mold in products that contain water.
I add vitamin E to most of my homemade lotions, oils, and butters at around 0.5% of the product by weight to help protect the oils from oxidation, thus extending the shelf life of my products.
Essential oils
Some essential oils, including tea tree, oregano, rosemary, and thyme essential oils, do show antimicrobial properties in studies. That doesn’t mean they can reliably preserve homemade skincare products on their own, though.
To function as true preservatives, essential oils would often need to be used at concentrations that could irritate the skin or increase the risk of sensitization.
While essential oils can add fragrance and may contribute some antimicrobial support, they are not considered reliable broad-spectrum preservatives for homemade lotions, creams, shampoos, or other water-based cosmetics.
While I don’t use them as preservatives, I do often add essential oils at around 1-2% of the recipe by weight to add a natural fragrance and other beneficial properties.
Rosemary extract
Like vitamin E, rosemary extract is primarily used as an antioxidant rather than a preservative.
It can help slow the oxidation of oils and extend the shelf life of oil-based ingredients, making it useful in products like balms, body oils, and salves. It’s commonly used in both cosmetic and food formulations for this purpose.
While rosemary extract can help delay rancidity, it does not provide reliable broad-spectrum protection against bacteria, yeast, or mold.
Rosemary extract can either be added at around 0.15-5% by weight directly to your oils or to the oil phase of a recipe to help extend the shelf life by protecting against oxidation of the fats.
Grapefruit seed extract
Grapefruit seed extract is often marketed as a natural preservative, but it remains highly controversial within the cosmetic formulation world.
Some studies have suggested that the antimicrobial activity found in certain grapefruit seed extract products may come from contamination with synthetic antimicrobial compounds rather than from the grapefruit extract itself.
In addition, grapefruit seed extract varies widely from supplier to supplier and is not generally considered a reliable broad-spectrum preservative for homemade cosmetics.
Because of the inconsistency and lack of reliable evidence supporting its effectiveness, I don’t recommend relying on grapefruit seed extract alone to preserve homemade skincare products.
Alternative preservation methods
Some ingredients can help preserve certain types of homemade products when used at high enough concentrations. While they aren’t usually used like standard broad-spectrum preservatives, they can still work well in certain situations.
Alcohol
Alcohol can help prevent microbial growth when used at sufficiently high concentrations. It also helps solubilize essential oils, making it especially useful in products like room sprays, linen sprays, and tinctures.
For preserving and extracting botanical ingredients, an alcohol content of at least 40% is typically recommended. That’s why many tinctures and extracts use vodka or stronger alcohols as their base. I use alcohol-based extraction methods in recipes like my homemade vanilla extract and homemade bitters.
In sprays and similar products, many formulators aim for roughly 20–30% alcohol in the final product to help reduce the risk of microbial growth.
Alcohol usually isn’t the best option for lotions, creams, or other emulsified skincare products, though, because the amount needed can feel drying or irritating on the skin.
Glycerin
Glycerin can also help preserve products when used at very high concentrations. It’s commonly used to make glycerites, which are botanical extracts made with glycerin instead of alcohol.
To reliably help prevent microbial growth, glycerin generally needs to make up more than half of the product, often around 55% or higher.
I’ve used glycerin-based extraction methods in recipes like my cucumber extract and non-alcohol vanilla extract.
While glycerin is an excellent humectant in smaller amounts, products with very high concentrations of glycerin tend to feel sticky or tacky on the skin. Because of that, glycerin usually isn’t used as the main way to preserve lotions, creams, or most other homemade skincare products.
Common natural broad-spectrum preservatives
No preservative is perfect for every recipe. Different preservatives work best at different pH ranges and in different types of products. Always check the recommended usage rate and effective pH range for the preservative you choose.
This section focuses mainly on preservatives commonly used in natural or ECOcert-style formulations, since those are the ones I’m asked about most often.
| Preservative | Effective pH range | Typical usage rate | ECOcert/COSMOS approved | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geogard ECT / Preservative ECO | 3–8 | ~0.6–1% | Yes | Broad-spectrum preservative with a somewhat noticeable scent |
| Geogard 221 / Cosgard | 2–6 | ~0.2–1% | Yes | Popular and easy to use in many emulsions |
| Sharomix 705 | Below 5.5–6 | ~0.6–1.2% | Yes | Works well in lower-pH formulations |
| Rokonsal BSB-N | Below 5.5 | ~0.2–1% | Yes | Mild preservative commonly used in natural formulations |
| Euxyl K903 | 3–6 | ~0.2–1% | Yes | Gentle preservative often used in baby or eye-area products |
| Dermorganics 1388 | 5–5.5 | ~2–4% | Yes | Works in a narrow pH range |
| Leucidal Liquid SF | Best below 6 | ~2–4% | Yes | Popular natural preservative, but somewhat controversial |
Geogard ECT / Preservative ECO
Geogard ECT (also sold as Preservative ECO) is a broad-spectrum preservative commonly used in natural skincare products. It works well in many lotions, creams, shampoos, and emulsions.
One downside is that it does have a somewhat noticeable scent that some people dislike, although fragrances or essential oils can often help mask it.
INCI: Benzyl Alcohol, Salicylic Acid, Glycerin, Sorbic Acid
Typical usage rate: Around 0.6–1%
Effective pH range: 3–8
Because it contains salicylic acid, it’s generally not recommended for leave-on products intended for babies.
Geogard 221 / Cosgard
Geogard 221, also known as Cosgard in some regions, is another popular preservative for natural formulations. It’s relatively easy to work with and is commonly used in lotions, creams, shampoos, and conditioners.
INCI: Benzyl Alcohol, Dehydroacetic Acid
Typical usage rate: 0.2–1%
Effective pH range: 2–6
It tends to work best in products with a pH below about 5.5.
Sharomix 705
Sharomix 705 is one of the natural broad-spectrum preservatives I’ve personally used the most over the years. It works best in products with a lower pH and is commonly used in emulsions and surfactant-based products.
INCI: Benzoic Acid, Sorbic Acid, Dehydroacetic Acid, Benzyl Alcohol
Typical usage rate: 0.6–1.2%
Effective pH range: Below 5.5–6
It’s generally considered heat stable, although prolonged exposure to high heat should still be avoided.
Rokonsal BSB-N
Rokonsal BSB-N is a mild broad-spectrum preservative commonly used in natural and organic cosmetic formulations.
INCI: Benzyl Alcohol, Glycerin, Benzoic Acid, Sorbic Acid
Typical usage rate: 0.2–1%
Effective pH range: Below 5.5
It’s often used in lotions, creams, and other lower-pH skincare products.
Euxyl K903
Euxyl K903 is considered a particularly gentle preservative and is often used in products designed for sensitive skin or the eye area.
INCI: Benzyl Alcohol, Benzoic Acid, Dehydroacetic Acid, Tocopherol
Typical usage rate: 0.2–1%
Effective pH range: 3–6
It tends to work especially well in lower-pH formulations.
Dermorganics 1388
Dermorganics 1388 works in a fairly narrow pH range, so checking the final pH of your product is especially important when using it.
INCI: Glycerin, Aqua, Sodium Levulinate, Sodium Anisate
Typical usage rate: 2–4%
Effective pH range: 5–5.5
Because it needs to be used at a higher percentage than many other preservatives, it can sometimes affect the final feel of a product.
Leucidal® Liquid SF
Leucidal is a radish root ferment preservative that became very popular in natural skincare because it appears to be a much more natural alternative to many conventional preservatives.
The antimicrobial peptides are derived from Leuconostoc kimchii, the same type of lactic acid bacteria used in making kimchi, a Korean fermented cabbage. Honestly, that was one of the things that originally made it sound so interesting to me.
When I first started making lotions and creams, I used Leucidal myself because I knew many readers were looking for more natural preservative options. I also liked the idea of using a ferment-derived preservative system instead of some of the harsher preservatives people were trying to avoid.
At first, I didn’t really notice any problems with it. The biggest downside for me was that it needed to be used at a much higher percentage than many other preservatives.
Over time, though, I started coming across more discussions questioning how reliable it really was as a broad-spectrum preservative, especially against mold. Then I found a study suggesting that the antimicrobial activity in some samples may not have actually been coming from the radish ferment itself, but instead from compounds like salicylic acid and quaternary ammonium compounds found in the samples tested.
“In summary, the antimicrobial activity of commercial Leuconostoc/radish root ferment filtrates (LRRFF) are attributed to salicylic acid and didecyldimethylammonium salts… We were unable to detect antimicrobial peptides in any sample of fermented radish root filtrate.”
J. Agric. Food Chem. 2015, 63, 11, 3053-305
INCI: Leuconostoc/Radish Root Ferment Filtrate
Typical usage rate: 2–4%
Effective pH range: Best below pH 6
That made me personally less comfortable relying on it as my main preservative system, especially for products with a longer shelf life.
That said, many people still use Leucidal successfully, and you’re welcome to experiment with it yourself if it fits your goals and comfort level.
What about Optiphen and Germall Plus?
If you search for preservatives online, especially on Amazon, you’ll probably also come across preservatives like Optiphen, Optiphen Plus, and Liquid Germall Plus. People ask me about those a lot too.
Unlike many of the preservatives discussed above, these aren’t usually considered “natural” preservatives and generally aren’t ECOcert or COSMOS approved. That said, a lot of DIYers and small businesses still use them successfully.
One reason they’re so popular is that they tend to be easier to work with than some natural preservative systems. Some also work over a wider pH range, which can make formulation a little less finicky.
I focused mainly on preservatives commonly used in more natural-style formulations because that’s what most of my readers are looking for. But that doesn’t mean preservatives like Optiphen or Germall Plus are automatically bad or unsafe.
Liquid Germall Plus
Liquid Germall Plus is probably one of the most commonly used preservatives in DIY skincare. It’s a broad-spectrum preservative used in products like lotions, creams, shampoos, and conditioners.
A lot of people like it because it’s effective at very low percentages and is generally considered easy to use.
Optiphen and Optiphen Plus
Optiphen preservatives are also very common in DIY skincare and cosmetic recipes. They’re often marketed as paraben-free alternatives and are commonly used in lotions and emulsified products.
Optiphen Plus tends to work better in products with a lower pH.
As with any preservative, it’s still important to check the manufacturer’s recommendations for things like pH range and suggested usage rates.
How to choose the right preservative
Choosing a preservative isn’t just about picking one labeled “natural” or swapping one preservative for another. Different preservatives work best in different types of products and under different conditions.
Using the correct dosage
When substituting one preservative for another, don’t automatically use the same percentage called for in the original recipe.
Always check the manufacturer’s recommended usage rate for the preservative you’re using. Some preservatives work well at very low percentages, while others, like Leucidal or Dermorganics 1388, need to be used at much higher amounts to be effective.
Using more preservative than recommended isn’t necessarily better, either. In some cases, higher percentages can affect the texture, scent, or feel of the final product.
Checking the pH range
Every preservative has a pH range where it works best. If the pH of your product falls outside that range, the preservative may not work effectively.
Most homemade skincare and haircare products are formulated somewhere around pH 4.5–5.5, which works well for both skin and many natural preservatives. True soap is one of the major exceptions because its naturally high pH changes how preservation works.
It’s also important to remember that some preservatives can slightly shift the pH of a product after they’re added. If you’re formulating a pH-sensitive product, it’s a good idea to check the pH again after adding your preservative.
Water-soluble vs. oil-soluble preservatives
Some preservatives work best in water-based products, while others can also be used in anhydrous products like sugar scrubs or body butters.
Most broad-spectrum preservatives used in homemade skincare work well in emulsions that combine water and oils, but it’s still important to check the supplier’s recommendations for compatibility and usage guidelines.
When in doubt, always check the documentation provided by the manufacturer or supplier.
Difficult-to-preserve ingredients
Some ingredients make products much more difficult to preserve safely, even when using a broad-spectrum preservative.
Fresh aloe vera, milk, fruit purees, honey, herbal infusions, and other food-like ingredients can increase the risk of microbial growth. Clays and fresh botanical ingredients can also complicate preservation.
That doesn’t mean you can never use those ingredients, but it does mean preservation becomes more challenging and less predictable.
For products with a longer intended shelf life, I usually prefer using ingredients that have already been commercially processed and preserved rather than adding fresh plant materials directly to homemade formulations.
Good manufacturing practices
Even the best preservative system can’t compensate for poor hygiene or heavily contaminated ingredients and equipment.
When making homemade skincare products, clean working conditions help reduce the number of microbes introduced into the product from the beginning, making preservation much easier and more reliable.
A few simple habits can make a big difference:
- Wash your hands well or wear gloves
- Sanitize work surfaces, tools, and containers
- Use distilled water when possible
- Avoid reusing containers that can’t be cleaned thoroughly
- Keep water out of anhydrous products whenever possible
- Store products in clean, airtight containers
Preservatives help slow microbial growth, but they don’t make a poorly handled product indestructible. Good formulation practices and proper storage are still important parts of making safe homemade skincare products.
Shelf life and realistic expectations
When large cosmetic companies develop products, they often perform microbial testing and preservative challenge testing to help verify that a product remains safe and stable over time.
Most home formulators are not doing that kind of testing, so shelf life estimates for homemade products are always somewhat approximate.
Even when using a broad-spectrum preservative, I usually recommend making relatively small batches of homemade skincare products and using them within a few months.
Products made with fresh ingredients, herbal infusions, milk, aloe vera, fruit purees, or other difficult-to-preserve ingredients may have a shorter shelf life and higher contamination risk.
Watch for signs of spoilage such as:
- changes in smell
- separation
- color changes
- mold growth
- gas buildup
- texture changes
While microbial contamination isn’t always visible, any noticeable change in smell, texture, appearance, or performance is a good reason to discard a product.
Conclusion
A lot of people start making their own skincare because they want more control over the ingredients they use. I’m the same way. But avoiding preservatives entirely doesn’t automatically make a product safer.
Once a product contains water, bacteria, yeast, and mold can become a real concern if it isn’t properly preserved. The good news is that there are several preservatives approved for natural and organic formulations, so it’s possible to make products that feel more natural while still helping protect against microbial growth.
Once you understand how water, pH, and different preservative systems work, choosing a preservative becomes much less intimidating.
FAQs
No. Vitamin E is an antioxidant, not a broad-spectrum preservative. It can help slow the oxidation of oils and delay rancidity, but it does not prevent the growth of bacteria, yeast, or mold in water-based products.
Usually, no. Products made only with oils, butters, and waxes generally don’t need a broad-spectrum preservative because microbes need water to grow.
That said, products used in the shower or with wet hands can still become contaminated over time if water gets into the container.
True liquid soap made with lye is generally considered self-preserving because of its naturally high pH. Most bacteria and mold struggle to grow well in that environment.
That said, things become more complicated if you add ingredients like milk, botanical extracts, aloe vera, or other difficult-to-preserve ingredients after dilution.
Essential oils may have some antimicrobial properties, but they are not considered reliable broad-spectrum preservatives for homemade skincare products.
In many cases, the amount needed to effectively preserve a product could irritate the skin or increase the risk of sensitization.
There isn’t one perfect preservative for every recipe, but preservatives like Geogard ECT, Geogard 221/Cosgard, or Sharomix 705 are commonly used in beginner-friendly natural skincare formulations.
The best choice depends on the type of product you’re making, its pH, and the ingredients you’re using.
Some preservatives are considered gentler than others, but it’s important to carefully check manufacturer recommendations and ingredient restrictions. For example, some preservatives containing salicylic acid are not generally recommended for leave-on baby products.
That depends on the ingredients, formulation, storage conditions, and preservative system used. Unlike commercial cosmetic companies, most home formulators are not performing microbial testing or preservative challenge testing, so it’s impossible to know the exact shelf life of a homemade product with certainty.
Even when using a broad-spectrum preservative, I usually prefer making relatively small batches and using them within a few months. One of my ingredient suppliers often recommends around 3 months as a reasonable estimate for many homemade products, even though some products may last longer under good conditions.
Products made with fresh ingredients, homemade infusions, milk, aloe vera, or fruit purees are often much more difficult to preserve and may have a shorter and less predictable shelf life.
Using more preservative than recommended doesn’t necessarily make a product safer. In some cases, it can affect the texture, scent, stability, or feel of the product and may increase the risk of irritation.
Always follow the manufacturer’s recommended usage rates.
Usually, yes, if the product contains water.
Refrigeration may help slow microbial growth, but it does not reliably prevent contamination in water-based skincare products. I like to compare it to food: refrigeration can help things last longer, but it doesn’t keep them safe indefinitely.
For very simple homemade products without a preservative, refrigeration may help them stay usable for a few days or possibly around a week, depending on the ingredients used. Beyond that, though, microbial growth becomes much more of a concern.
Preservatives help reduce the risk of microbial growth, but they are not magic. Mold can still form if:
– the preservative wasn’t used at the correct percentage
– the product’s pH was outside the preservative’s effective range
– difficult-to-preserve ingredients were used
– the product became heavily contaminated during use
– the preservative system wasn’t broad-spectrum or compatible with the formula
That’s why formulation, pH, packaging, and good manufacturing practices all matter too.
Originally published November 12, 2019. Updated and expanded in May 2026 with additional information, updated graphics, and expanded FAQs.
After reading this page and doing some research I settled on Rokonsal BSB-N. However, I am unable to find a supplier in the US. Not even Amazon has it!!!Have you come across any suppliers in the US?
Thank you!
Hi Charlee,
I live in Spain, so I’m not sure what’s available there. I’ve been meaning to look into better options for the US as most of my readers are from there. Sadly, the formulation classes I’ve taken are also based in the UK, so most of the ingredients have focused on things available and used most in Europe.
hi Tracy, i would like to ask a question, i’m gonna make moisturizer spray for my skin with only 2 ingredients, 30 grams glycerin + 70 grams distilled water, is it really need a preservative or not?
Hi Arfthan,
That’s a very interesting question, and one that I tried to research, but couldn’t find a definitive answer.
I guess, if it were me, I’d add one. This is my reasoning…
Honey is self-preserving on its own, but the second you add it to other products, it’s a nightmare to preserve. While glycerin is a bit different than honey and can preserve things at high concentrations, I’d be worried about watering it down. I think it could definitely feed microbes at a lower concentration. So, to be safe, yes, I’d use a preservative.
Arfhan & Tracy you may find the answer here: https://www.mezzonifoods.com/blog/is-glycerin-a-preservative/ (on the safe side I ‘d make it 75% glycerine and 25% water in order for the mix to be self-preserved)
Hi Tracy,
Love your article! I am having trouble finding a preservative that’s good for leave-in products especially for afro-textured hair. My mixture is water oil mixture, I was wondering what are your thoughts about this? Thank you soo much.
Hi Jordan,
It shouldn’t matter that it is a leave-in product. The above-mentioned preservatives are used for lotions and other products that are left on your skin, so they should be fine left on your hair.
When you say water oil mixture, do you mean it’s an emulsion or a bi-phase product like my salt spray? If bi-phase, you’d probably want water-soluble. If an emulsion, it probably doesn’t really matter so much.
I hope that makes sense.
Hi Tracy,
I’m trying to dab into selling body scrubs and can’t figure which preservative would work best. The body scrubs I make a salt base with oils including essential oils. I also make sugar lip scrubs and I’m not sure what will work best since it is for the lips. Thank you in advance for any insight!
Hi Tsvety,
When making products to sell, it’s probably best to do some sort of microbial testing to ensure that your product is safe. In many countries that is legally required, but not all countries (like the US- which doesn’t) do.
I think a preservative like Euxyl k900 would be a great alternative for this, but, again, I think you should have it tested (ideally after intentionally contaminating it with water, etc.) to make sure that it really works well for the shelf life you are trying to achieve. When choosing a preservative, you’ll have to take a look at the recommended dosage for that preservative. (For Euxyl, it’s 0.5-1% by weight.) With this having an emulsifier, I don’t think you’d have a problem with water-soluble preservatives either, but, again, it’s always best to test them out.
As for use for lips. To be honest, I’ve never added a preservative to my homemade lip scrubs or lip balms, but, on the other hand, I don’t sell them either. I could try to ask in one of my groups, but I’d suggest asking your supplier if whatever preservative you use is safe for use on lips. (The main concern there is that people could injest it.)
I think that one should be safe, but I’m not positive. It would be best to get confirmation from a supplier!
Hi Tracy,
I am totally new to lotion making. Doing a whole lot of reading but can’t find a definite answer to which preservative is good for lotions made for babies. I am trying to make lotion for my year old twin babies who are sensitive to almost every thing I have used commercially bought. I found this water based colloidal oats lotion formula and it has been working wonders but it suggested to use preservative eco. To avoid preservatives I just made lotion in small batches and used it up quickly but as I have to return to work I wanna make it in large batches and was honestly confused which preservative to use. Everyone explains about preservative but no one tells of it’s safe for babies. You are the first person I came across who said Euxyl® K 903 was safe for baby products. I believe I can use it for the lotion. But the whipped butter I make for them I have found condensation in the lid and jar due to temp changes. What preservative is safe to use in this case?
Hi Riya,
Yes, Eukyl is safe for babies- as is Cosgard. They are both quite gentle.
I’m not sure I fully understand the question about the butter. Is this a body butter that only has oils and butters (and, perhaps waxes)?
Your issue is condensation on the bottle cap, but that’s probably only when you first make it, right?
You can just wait to cap it until it has fully cooled. That should solve the problem of condensation.
If it’s a product without water, there really is no need for a preservative, as long as you are careful when using it, and try not to contaminate it with water. In any case, Euxyl is a good choice for butters as it is oil-soluble.
Hi I have been making homemade lotions and such for quiet some time now and have only ever used vitamin E gel capsules to help with preservation…..but I’m trying to make a good face moisturizer for my acnr prone skin and want to start using a preservative to enhance the shelf life of my products but I am unsure of what to use??? Can you please tell me a good universal preservative for my homemade products? Any help is very much appreciated..thank you!!
Hi Jenna,
It’s very difficult to name a “universal” preservative as it will depend on the product you are making. That said, most of the more popular ones will work in many (most) applications. I have been using Sharomix a lot and Euxyl k903 is also great. They are very versatile. Those are easy to find in my area. Depending on where you live, you may find that other preservatives are easier for you to find.
Hi Tracy!
Thank you so much for all this helpful info! I’ll admit I am new and currently doing the research to create my organic herbal skin + body care line! For sprays, toners that will essentially have herbal infusions (water) with herbal oils (oils) together, what preservative would best suit this type of product that would 100% be organic and natural? I’m skeptical still about using preservatives at all although it seems like Euxyl® K 903 and alcohol are the healthiest, cleanest options.
Would you agree with that? Do you have any advice?
Thank you so much!
Hello,
To be honest, I still need to update my posts that include only water and oils. (I’m slowly making my way through all of the older posts on my blog!) Ideally, you would need to solubilize the oils in the water. That can be done with a high-strength alcohol or with a solubilizer. Solubilizers can be mixed with the oils, and once the oils are incorporated, the mixture can be diluted with water.
If you were to use alcohol, it would serve both purposes (preserving and solubilizing) as long as you didn’t dilute it too far.
If you wanted to use Euxyl, you really should solubilize the oils into the water first, otherwise the preservative may not be protecting both the water and oil phases, if that makes sense.
Obviously, you don’t want to overuse preservatives, but if you are careful with the dosage, the more natural preservatives are definitely safer than not using a preservative. Good natural and/or organic cosmetics use them too. (Yes, both alcohol and Euxyl are acceptable for organic certification.)
If I use ethanol as a preservative for my infused Calendula cream. Would this preservative (ethanol) be enough or would I need two preservatives?
Hi Kenyce,
When using ethanol as a preservative, you need to have the alcohol concentration of the final product be above 20-25%. That’s obviously not ideal for a cream as it would end up being drying to the skin.
For a cream, I’d suggest using one of the broad-spectrum preservatives available for sale on the market.
Hi Tracy, thanks for your article!
Is there a particular reason why Dehydroacetic Acid is almost always used in combination with Benzyl Alcohol and/or Benzoic Acid? Why can I not use only Dehydroacetic Acid in my formulation?
Have a great day!
Hi Alex,
I’m sorry for the late reply. I was actually in the middle of taking a course in natural cosmetic preservatives, and wanted to finish the course before answering- in case I found a more thorough answer for you.
Really, the only thing I found was that they said that generally, you need a combination of different types of preservative components to ensure that you have broad spectrum protection. That is especially true with the more natural preservatives (that aren’t as strong as the parabens, for example.)
Generally, some of the components are good against bacteria, others are good against certain bacteria, and yet others are good against other bacteria.
Even after taking a course in it, I wouldn’t feel confident in trying to preserve something without using a pre-mixed blend. You’d have to do a lot of microbial testing on your products to ensure that they are really staying free of problematic microbes- and that can cost a lot of money.
It isn’t worth it for me.
I’d prefer to use tried-and-true preservative blends.
Hi Tracy, what is your recommendation for a natural Hyaluronic serum perservative?
Thank you
Hi Jack! I usually use Sharomix in mine, but you should be able to use whatever water-soluble preservative that you can find locally.
If a recipe calls for castile soap and water, will it need a preservative?
Hi Kathleen,
If it only has Castile soap and you are only diluting it somewhat with water (like for using in a foaming dispenser), in most cases you should be fine, at least for a while. It’s unlikely that you will be lowering the pH of it very much with only water. I wouldn’t highly dilute large amounts, though. Just dilute what you can use in a relatively short amount of time.
It’s all about the pH. It should still be higher than where most pathogenic microbes grow (and above the range where most preservatives are effective anyway.)
If you’re uneasy about it, you can try one of the preservatives I’ve mentioned for liquid soap. (But, as I said, I have personally never used one with my soaps.)
Tracy,
Thank you for the reply. That makes sense. Would you recommend using PH strips for lotions, soaps, etc?
Hi Kathleen,
Yes. They work fine. You don’t really need to know a super precise measurement, so I find that pH strips work well. I talk more about testing the pH in my new post about the importance of pH in cosmetics.
Hi Tracy,
I’d like to know which preservative would be best for use in a lotion and is also safest on a baby’s skin. I currently have Cosgard but haven’t found any info on whether or not it’s definitively safe for babies. Since I plan on making some lotion as a gift, a skin test isn’t feasible.
Thank you!
Hi Roseanna,
Sorry for the late response. I meant to look into it more closely and get back to you and then forgot. I found this way back with a bunch of unasnswered spam.
My supplier has it listed as a very gentle preservative (Cosgard/Geogard). They do recommend it for baby products and for body lotions recommend a dosage of 0.6-0.8%. I’m not quite sure why, but they recommend a dosage of 1.15% for facial creams. (It doesn’t make a lot of sense that you’d need more for an emulsion for your face than for your body to me.)
Ideally, yes, a product should be tested- which is especially true for items meant for others, but, of course, most of us aren’t going to test if we make a product that isn’t for sale. Just make sure that the people you give the gift to understand that you are using a natural preservative and that, while it should keep for longer than that, it’s best to use it up within 2-3 months if no testing has been done on it. 😉
Do you have an opinion on Optiphen in lotions. I am researching preservatives for lotions to expand my product line. Thank you
Hi Martha,
It seems to be more common in the Americas and Australia than here in Europe. That’s why I’ve never used it. It just isn’t a preservative I’ve seen here before. I haven’t researched it a lot, but it should be fine to use.
Hi Tracy, thanks for such valuable information.
Can I use Cosgard in an oil-glycerine (no water) body scrub?
How about in a melt and pour soap that has hydrosols added?
Do they actually need a preservative?
Thanks so much in advance. Have a lovely day!!!
Hi Dee,
It’s difficult to comment on “melt and pour soaps” as a group in general because there is a huge variety amongst them. Some are actually real soap with other additives added to allow them to be melted. Others (most I’ve seen!) aren’t actually really soap and are really detergent bars instead.
Depending on the ingredients, their pH will probably be completely different. Real soap melt and pour soaps will have a higher pH and probably won’t need it. If you are adding water, as long as they are still hardening up into soap, they should be fine. If they are detergent bars with a low pH, adding too much extra water may throw off the preservatives they have used (which are normally dosed by weight percentage). You could check the ingredients and/ or the pH. (I talk about testing the pH in my latest post about pH in cosmetics.) If it’s a detergent bar and has a lower pH and you add too much water, you may want to add a preservative at the dosage for the amount of liquid added.
As for Cosgard in an oil-only product… I don’t think it would work, unless it’s an emulsified scrub with some sort of emulsifier. Cosgard is water-soluble. You’d need an oil-soluble preservative. (Something like Euxyl® K903 should work.)
Hi Tracy! Do you know anything about using citric acid as a naturual preservative?
Hello,
Citric acid wouldn’t be a very good preservative on its own, unless you used it to bring down the pH enough to bring the product down below a pH of 3-4, making it less hospitable to microbes. That’s not generally the ideal way to preserve things, though, as extreme pH’s aren’t generally ideal for skin or hair.
The broad-spectrum preservatives on the market are generally (or all?) a combination of various different acids and other substances. Together they can better prevent a wide variety of microbes that might negatively affect your products.